Artist: Bon Jovi
Album: Crush
This is a first for the Random Songs–a song that I didn’t like.
Crush was the second Bon Jovi CD that I purchased, after Cross Road. In some ways, Crush was a bit of a surprise, as several of the songs didn’t sound like what I was used to from Cross Road. I could deal with that, though, since it’s never fair to compare a Greatest Hits compilation to a regular release.
Captain Crash was a bit of an anomaly though; it’s one on a relatively short list of Bon Jovi songs that I instantly disliked the first time I heard it. I wasn’t sure why; it didn’t drag like some of the others on Crush, and it wasn’t annoying or anything. In fact, the tune was a solid pop-rock tune almost as good as It’s My Life. I just Did Not Like It.
If I had to guess, I’d say that the nonsensical quality of the lyrics put me off, but that doesn’t add up either. I love I Would Do Anything For Love, and that song doesn’t exactly make a ton of sense. (You can read the Random Song for I Would Do Anything For Love here.)
It didn’t get better with time, either. Many of the other songs that I had instantly disliked (If I Was Your Mother, Tom Sawyer) I eventually warmed up to after many hearings. In some cases, like If I Was Your Mother, I would eventually come to really like the song. But Captain Crash just didn’t do anything for me, no matter how many times I listened to Crush.
It wasn’t until I attended my first concert (Prudential Center, November 3, 2007) that I finally got it. When I heard the first notes of the song, my first thought was “oh no, anything but this”. But once I heard more of it, I started to get into it. This is a song that somehow undergoes a magical transformation when played live. I don’t know what it is about live performance that completely transforms this song, but it somehow becomes a marvelous experience at a concert.
I still don’t really like the studio recording. Even though I enjoy hearing it live, and swaying along with the rest of the crowd at concerts is part of the show that I really look forward to, I just can’t get into the studio version. Something about it just seems kind of hollow compared to hearing it live. It’s too bad that a live version of Captain Crash and The Beauty Queen From Mars wasn’t included on One Wild Night, because that would be one of my favorite songs. Maybe. I don’t know if the magic of the live show would carry over to the recording.